In November 2023, Conroe ISD trustees, not unlike other Texas public school districts as of late, decided they needed to get tougher about books on their shelves. They voted to approve revisions to the district's book review process, one of which would allow only one trustee to appeal a decision...
With a growing number of titles banned across the district, some teachers in Conroe ISD were asked to box up and return thousands of books from their classroom collections.In November 2023, Conroe ISD trustees, not unlike other Texas public school districts as of late, decided they needed to get tougher about books on their shelves.
According to district records, over 30 library titles have been banned since November, with six removed from junior high shelves, of which four are pending review at the high school level. Per February's advisory list, another ten books may be restricted or removed depending on the outcome likely decided later this month.
Although most of the over 60 books this parent request to be removed remained on shelves and in classrooms, 15 were restricted to certain grade levels or banned entirely. Another four titles were initially removed before winter break but then were re-designated as"Parent & Counselor Resources." The instructor took to Facebook to post a photo of the books packed in boxes. The teacher said at least 40 people, including Advanced Placement instructors, were begging for these titles. Frank Strong, co-director of the Texas Freedom to Read Project, re-shared the teacher's photos on"Often the only way this gets noticed is if a teacher sees the books being removed or a teacher gets an email saying to remove books because it doesn't happen at a board meeting," Strong said.
Russey said district personnel don't indicate why a removed or restricted book does not meet district criteria. Instead of classifying whether the work is educationally unsuitable or pervasively vulgar, they only state that it does not meet the standards outlined in the district's local regulation policies for approved library and instructional materials.
“A lot of teachers are just plain nervous,” the teacher said. “Teachers who have taught for years and are now substitutes — because they retired — don’t want to bring attention to themselves. They are scared.” "It's a deliberative process. It can be frustratingly slow. I understand that. But, it is a rational, calm process that makes sense and seems to work," Strong said."Whereas, the internal review process inherently lacks transparency, because we don't know necessarily what the criteria are, how books are being measured against the criteria or who is doing it."
Odenweller returned a list of the texts in the list provided by the group that she had already looked into and said she would follow up regarding the leftover titles. Most of these books align with the titles the district banned recently. A Conroe ISD parent who served on a reconsideration committee and requested she remain anonymous for this story said she was pleasantly surprised by what she thought was a fair process. She added that everyone on the committee listened to what each other had to say after reading the challenged book.
Indonesia Berita Terbaru, Indonesia Berita utama
Similar News:Anda juga dapat membaca berita serupa dengan ini yang kami kumpulkan dari sumber berita lain.
Controversy Surrounding Houston ISD District Advisory CommitteeMembers of the Houston ISD District Advisory Committee face potential consequences for sharing meeting information with the press and public. The committee is divided on the issue of transparency, with concerns raised about unethical behavior and negative comments on social media.
Baca lebih lajut »
Houston ISD's New Education System Shows Promising ResultsHouston Independent School District's new education system, implemented by superintendent Mike Miles, has shown positive results in recent exams. However, Miles emphasizes that this is just one data set and more work needs to be done.
Baca lebih lajut »
BooksBook reviews, book news and author interviews. Articles about bestselling fiction and non-fiction from the Los Angeles Times.
Baca lebih lajut »
Can Employee Ownership Trust Protect Brands Long-Term?When a big business buys a beloved brand then changes the product, lowers the quality, or shutters the company altogether, consumers aren’t the only ones who feel the sting — the founders themselves often regret selling.
Baca lebih lajut »
The Changing Landscape of Childhood PlayResearchers say the way kids play has quietly transformed over the past three decades, with fewer children playing outside.
Baca lebih lajut »